The Courage to Be Happy by Ichiro Kishimi and Fumitake Koga taught me that self-reliance
is not a stronger “me” but freedom from “me.” It took me the whole book to see that, and I
want to walk you through how I got there.
This is the sequel to The Courage to Be Disliked. Written again as a dialogue, it takes
Adler’s ideas out of theory and tests them where they are hardest to live by: in
classrooms, workplaces and our closest relationships.
I read it with my practitioner’s toolkit open beside me. Again and again, I found Adler
hiding inside tools I use every day as a psychometrist and facilitator: Transactional
Analysis, the drama triangle, facilitation ground rules, the SCARF model. This review is as
much about those connections as about the book.
Education begins with respect
The book opens with a simple claim: the objective of education is self-reliance, helping
people become independent adults. And the knowledge we need to live happily is
knowledge about humans, how to live in a community and interact with others. That is
learned in groups, not alone, which is why counsellors and teachers both serve the same
goal.
It starts with an inner alignment that anyone familiar with Transactional Analysis will
recognise: “I’m OK, you’re OK,” the healthiest of the life positions Eric Berne described. I
am OK, I have the ability; you are OK, others are good people. Not as ideals, but as
something concrete we practise.
The practice is respect. Borrowing from Erich Fromm, respect is the ability to see a person
as they are and to value them for being exactly that person. Not with a desire to change
them, but letting them grow and unfold in their own way. The moment we push or correct,
respect disappears.
Where there is fear, there is no respect either. Speaking through fear, the book says, is like
shouting into an empty room. And the line I loved most here: respect, like courage and
cowardice, is contagious.
Empathy, too, is described beautifully, as walking side by side with another: seeing what
they see, hearing what they hear. It is not a feeling we wait for but a skill we learn.
Page 1 of 5
The Courage to Be Happy — Book Review
The past is a story we choose
Adler’s teleology says we give meaning to past events. If we don’t want to be at the mercy
of our past, we have to see it as it is: not a reality, but the meaning we give it to suit our
present. Whether that story turns out positive or negative depends on whether we stay
stuck in our current reality. In fact, we quietly edit the past to suit our present. Events that
run counter to our story get erased.
Those who are stuck keep replaying the same negative recording in their heads. The book
calls it getting drunk on the cheap wine of tragedy. It is a phrase I will not forget.
To explain this, the book draws a triangular prism. One side reads “that bad person,”
another “poor me,” and the third “what should I do from now on?” Most of our stories are
told from the first two sides only.
As a practitioner, this immediately reminded me of Stephen Karpman’s drama triangle,
another idea from Transactional Analysis, with its victim, persecutor and rescuer. Adler’s
prism goes one step further: it doesn’t just describe the trap, it points to the exit. The
third side is the only one that moves us forward.
There is a hidden cost to staying on the first two sides. Retelling “poor me” or “that bad
person” brings solace, but it also reinforces the hurt. Repeat the story every day, and we
come to expect others to keep comforting us. Without noticing, we have become
dependent on them.
The gentler alternative is to say: “I have been through a lot, and I am OK with it.” To affirm
that the past was unhappy, and still accept the present. That, the book suggests, is where
satisfaction begins.
Neither praise nor rebuke
Adler is clear that the success of education does not depend on praise or rebuke; both are
a problem. Yet respect alone is not enough either. A community also needs rules, and they
must be created democratically, by the people and for the people. A strong parallel is
visible in the simple ways of working of the IAF (International Association of Facilitators),
where a group agrees on its own ground rules before the work begins. The sovereign of a
conversation is its participants, not the facilitator.
From there the book turns to reward and punishment, and argues that we need neither. To
show why, it lays out five stages of problem behaviour, a ladder each child may climb:
- Demand for admiration: “praise me.” Effort goes into earning praise or a privileged
position, not into the work itself. - Attention-drawing: when praise doesn’t come, any attention will do. Negative
attention arrives faster than positive.
Page 2 of 5
The Courage to Be Happy — Book Review - Power struggle: open defiance, or quiet disobedience and pretending not to hear. Like
a rally in tennis, the child serves, and we hit the ball back by shouting. - Revenge: having lost the struggle, a person seeks to be disliked rather than ignored. At
this stage, outside help is often needed. - Proof of incompetence: “don’t expect anything from me.” Rather than try and fail, they
stop trying, so they will not be hurt again.
Every stage grows from the same root: the need to belong and to hold a special place in
the community. I connected this to the SCARF model from neuroscience, where threats
to Status and Relatedness trigger the same defensive responses.
The book is equally clear about how adults respond. Violence is an immature form of
communication, a shortcut when we are tired or want acceptance without effort. Anger
and tears are low-cost forms of it. Even a calm reprimand is violence, because the child
doesn’t know it is an empty bullet. I loved that image.
Praise is no better. It plants competition in the community and teaches the child that
other people are enemies. Both reward and punishment are ultimately ways to keep
someone under control, and both stand in the way of self-reliance.
This one landed close to home. As a child, I longed for praise and felt its absence as a
deficiency. Looking back now, I can see that much of my drive to outperform was really a
drive to be praised, to be seen as competent. The first step of that ladder, “praise me,” was
once my own.
Not being able to start the conversation from “what should I do from now on” is no excuse.
As the serenity prayer puts it, we begin with what we can change. The book also borrows
Kant: our immaturity is not a lack of reason, but a lack of courage to use it without
someone else’s direction.
Born incomplete, built for community
Why is belonging so powerful? Because every one of us starts out incomplete. In
childhood, all humans without exception feel inferior. It may sound pessimistic, but the
book turns it around: precisely because we are weak, community feeling is built into us. It
is part of what makes us human.
Our most fundamental need is to belong. Isolation leads to social death, and eventually to
biological death.
But seeking belonging through approval is a trap with no end. People who depend on
approval become like clockwork dolls that won’t move until someone winds them up.
Letting others decide my worth is dependence. Deciding it myself is self-reliance.
Page 3 of 5
The Courage to Be Happy — Book Review
The book asks a sharp question: why does “you are an ordinary person” feel like an insult?
Instead of placing worth on being different, we can place worth on being ourselves, even
if that is ordinary. This is what the book calls the courage to be normal.
And one line every leader should hear: a person’s worth is decided not by the kind of work
they do, but by the attitude with which they do it.
Trust, confidence, and a mirror
Adler describes three life tasks: work, friendship and love. All human problems, he says,
are interpersonal relationship problems, and so all joy is interpersonal relationship joy.
Work rests on division of labour, the survival strategy humans developed to make up for
physical weakness. It runs on trust: believing in someone on conditions, the way a bank
lends against collateral. Friendship asks for something deeper, confidence, which means
believing in the person, not in their conditions.
This is where the book held up a mirror to me. A while ago, I had archived a WhatsApp
group. An acquaintance gently suggested I enjoy the conversations instead: go in, come
out, and watch the group behaviour. It struck me as odd. Then I realised I don’t know how
to engage unless I like the people. I engage fully, heart and soul, or not at all.
I had quietly thought of this as a strength, even felt a little superior for it. The book
showed me otherwise. Others can work comfortably through relationships of trust,
cooperating whether or not they like everyone. That is a skill I am still learning, and here
was an acquaintance teaching it to me.
The book offers a way forward that moved me deeply. Ideas offered with distrust go in one
ear and out the other, however valid they are. So whoever wants to be heard must believe
in the other person first, even while that person is trying not to believe. For anyone who
coaches or leads, that question of who goes first sits at the heart of every relationship.
There is a caution too. When we try to save someone, we are often trying to save
ourselves. The book names it the messiah complex. It is the rescuer from the drama
triangle again, a role our profession constantly tempts us into.
Self-reliance, redefined
The final task is love, which Fromm calls far more difficult than any other. The book traces
a beautiful progression. Pursuing my happiness builds work relationships. Pursuing your
happiness builds friendship. Love builds the happiness of an inseparable “us,” where
neither me nor you comes first.
Page 4 of 5
The Courage to Be Happy — Book Review
Happiness, in the book’s words, is the feeling of contribution. We know our worth only
when we feel useful to someone. Give, and it shall be given unto you.
Then comes the twist I didn’t see coming. Love connects to happiness because love is
liberation from “me.” For a happy life, the “me” must vanish. Reading this, I thought of
Sunya in Indian philosophy, and of letting go of ahankar, the ego. Two traditions, centuries
apart, arriving at the same place.
The book is honest about what stands in the way. Weakness can become a frighteningly
powerful weapon. Some adults use their hurt, misfortune or troubled past to control
others, by making them worry. Adler calls this the pampered-child lifestyle, the wish to
remain the centre of the world.
And so the book comes full circle. It began by saying the goal of education is self-reliance,
and we nodded, assuming it meant standing on our own. It ends by revealing what self
reliance really is: breaking away from self-centredness, and from “me” itself.
That is why happiness takes courage. If you have read The Courage to Be Disliked, read
this one next. And if you work with people, read it slowly, with your own toolkit open
beside you.
Page 5 of 5